retirement

Why Your First RMD Is Taxed More Heavily When You Also Collect Social Security

An RMD is taxed as ordinary income. That much is well known. What surprises people is that it also changes how much of your Social Security is taxed. The same withdrawal can cost far more in tax for someone who collects benefits than for someone who does not.

The numbers below come from this site's RMD calculator, run for one example household. Change any input there to see your own.

The example

A single filer, age 73, living in a state with no income tax, in 2026. Prior year-end traditional IRA balance of $500,000. Other taxable income of $20,000 (a pension, say). Tax is figured after the standard deduction ($16,100), the additional deduction for people 65 and over ($2,050) and the senior deduction ($6,000). The only thing that differs between the two columns below is $30,000 a year of Social Security.

No Social SecurityWith Social Security
First RMD$18,868$18,868
Federal tax caused by the RMD$1,518$3,965
Tax as a share of the RMD8.0%21.0%

The withdrawal is identical, divisor 26.5 from the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table. The tax is not. With benefits in the picture, the RMD costs $2,447 more.

Why the same withdrawal costs more

Social Security benefits are taxed in steps, based on your provisional income: your other income (including any tax-exempt interest) plus half your benefits. Below a threshold none of the benefits are taxed. Above it, up to 85% of them can be (26 U.S.C. 86; the worksheet is in IRS Publication 915).

In the example, before the RMD, $5,350 of the benefits are taxable. Add the RMD to income and that rises to $21,388. The RMD did two things at once:

  1. It added its own amount to taxable income.
  2. It pushed $16,038 more of the benefits into taxable income.

So the IRA withdrawal is taxed once as itself and once through the extra benefits it makes taxable. That second layer is mostly why the tax share rises from 8.0% to 21.0%.

What to take from it

  • The RMD is not the only number to plan around. If you collect benefits, the cost of a withdrawal depends on how much of the benefits it uncovers.
  • Years before RMDs start are the cheaper window. Starting age is 73 in this example. Converting some of an IRA to a Roth in earlier, lower-income years shrinks later RMDs. Run it in the Roth conversion calculator, and compare the totals across years, not only the first one.
  • Your own thresholds differ. Filing status changes the thresholds in the law, and your other income changes where you land. The example is one household, not a typical one.

Method and sources

Figures come from the RMD calculator for the inputs above, with federal tax on the 2026 brackets. The first-year divisor is from the Uniform Lifetime Table in IRS Publication 590-B. Social Security taxation follows 26 U.S.C. 86 as worked in IRS Publication 915. The calculator's methodology page lists the assumptions and what it leaves out, including state treatment of benefits.

Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. The information provided should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional financial guidance. Consult a licensed financial advisor before making financial decisions.